Review: Watchmen – Alan Moore & Dave Gibbons

17 Feb



How does one write a review for this? I haven’t even tried to go back through the years and read all the thousands of previous reviews for Watchmen – after all, I would then be spouting what all the previous reviewers had said about the book, wouldn’t I? There opinion(s) would colour mine. So, here we go.

Watchmen is, first and foremost, a book. Something like this cannot be lumped together with ‘comics’ or ‘graphic novels’. That, my friends, would be sacriledge. The best writers in the business today would, I’m sure, give both kidneys to write such a multilayered and astounding piece of work. Mr Moore, I would like to breathe the same air you were breathing when you scripted this, no doubt about that.

So, that aside, lets get to it: For those who haven’t read Watchmen, and you really should, your lives will be better for it, this is the basic premise:

Imagine a world very much like ours – Nixon, Robert Redford, JFK, America and Russia in the Cold War – with one small difference that starts off everything – people dressing in masks and prowling the night, bringing criminals to justice. They wear costumes, but don’t have powers. They aren’t rich playboys or respected journalists, but writers for bird-journals and mechanics and homeless crazies. And from the opening scene, you realize that they’ve had their day. Go on, retire, thanks but no thanks, us real lawgivers will carry on, thank you. By and large they weren’t rewarded or commended – in fact, they’re being killed. Someone is going around killing them, and New York just doesn’t really care.

Enter Rorschach, one of the best, most sublimely realized heroes I’ve ever had the pleasure reading about. This guy, to a certain degree, is like Michael Corleone in that he is single-minded and absolutely doesn’t care, because he knows what he’s about, and what he has to do – even if those who once stood in costume by his side have retired. He knows something is wrong, knows that they’re being targeted…

But this book is not only about him. It’s also about America itself, about the Russians of that time and the shared paranoia; it’s about how subtley different the world could have been if someone crazy enough had put on a mask and hit the streets to kick criminal ass; it’s about how even mass-murderers must go free so that peace (and as Watchmen shows, our idea of peace is twisted) reigns; it’s about forgiving even the vilest crimes and finding something to love in the perpetrator; it’s about the lone survivor of a pirate ship, slowly going mad; it’s about how even societies evils can create something that is a better example of justice than any court or judge; it’s a story about so, so many things, important things that we, all of us, have forgotten in the name of this strange idea of ‘peace’ that we think we know…

I was blown away by this. Utterly and completely. This will stand through the decades and centuries the way Shakespeare’s works do, I promise you that. But not because it’s brilliant, engaging, a mirror that offers understanding instead of reflection, or simply horrifying, but because it is ageless and speaks to the deepest parts of us that money and entertainment and civilization has buried.

Christopher Lee says that he reads the Lord of the Rings every year… Watchmen will be my come-back-to, because it’ll always offer something new, something deep, something timeless.

I’m not going to score this. And I defy anybody who ever has. This is brillience, pure and simple.

Order it here.


Posted by on February 17, 2009 in Reviews


5 responses to “Review: Watchmen – Alan Moore & Dave Gibbons

  1. Mark Chitty

    February 17, 2009 at 10:27 pm

    Dave, after reading that I’m now banging my head against the wall for not already reading it!

    I. Must. Get. This.

  2. edifanob

    February 18, 2009 at 3:37 pm

    I read it last year and it is extraordinary!!

    If you didn’t read it so far….just do it!!!!

    By the way release date of WATCHMEN movie: 5th of March 2009.

  3. goldnsilver

    February 19, 2009 at 10:00 am

    He, I scored it. But I gave it five out of five because I’m such an Alan Moore groupie.

    Nice review, you eloquently explained why Watchmen is so brilliant and why its so important.

    One of the good sides of the film coming out is that it will direct more people to the original comic (hoping that the director doesn’t massacre it that bad that people scoff at the idea of the real comic, not understanding its brilliance).

    • Dave-Brendon de Burgh

      February 19, 2009 at 10:18 am

      Thanks for the thumbs-up of my review. 🙂 Yè, after reading it, I’m very worried about the movie, but the book will always be there, unchanged and brilliant, even if the movie is a screw-up, so I console myself with that. 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s



C.T. Phipps

Author of horror, sci-fi, and superheroes.

M.D. Thalmann

M.D. Thalmann, a novelist and freelance journalist with an affinity for satire and science fiction, lives in Phoenix, Arizona with his wife, children, and ornery cats, reads too much and sleeps too little.

Greyhart Press

Publisher of Science Fiction, Fantasy, Horror, and Thrillers

Joseph D'Lacey

My pen is my compass. I appear to have lost my pen.

This Is Horror

The Voice of Horror


Book, comic and sometimes film reviews

The Talkative Writer

Musings by speculative fiction author Karen Miller

Cohesion Press

The Battle Has Just Begun

Indie Hero

Brian Marggraf, Author of Dream Brother: A Novel, Independent publishing advocate, New York City dweller

Paws in the Porridge

'She is like a muse...who kicks people in the face.'

Matthew Sylvester

father, author, martial artist



Shannon A Thompson

Young Adult Science Fiction and Fantasy Author

%d bloggers like this: